‘What does the expert witness process actually involve?’

No items found.

‘What does the expert witness process actuallyinvolve?’

The second in a short series of articles written by Emma Bracher, Careand OT Expert and associate of Maggie Sargent & Associates.

So, you’ve been instructed. What now?

There can be quite a few steps involved in the expert witness process, and a case can take months or even years to reach its conclusion. Here’s an idea of what you might expect along the way.

Step 1: Receiving the instruction

You'll first receive a letter of approach asking whether you're able to take on a case. If it's within your expertise and you hve the capacity, you can accept the approach and be put forward to the solicitor. Remember, this doesn't guarantee you'll be appointed – the solicitor may have approached a number of other experts.

If appointed, you will receive a formal letter of instruction (LOI), usually laying out the background of the case in more detail, and detailing what the solicitor wants you to address in your report. You will need to review the LOI as soon as it’s received to ensure the case is what you were expecting, you fully understand the solicitors’ requirements, and everything required is within your area of expertise.

Step 2: Preparing for yourassessment

You'll usually receive medical records, any previous reports and other relevant documentation. You’ll need to make sure that you have enough time review these before your assessment. If you don’t have all the documents that you need, make sure that you ask for them.

Having a good assessment template helps, ideally one that you have personalised for the claimant and case prior to your visit, to make sure you gather all the information you need for your report.

Step 3: Assessing the claimant

Assessment time will vary depending on the case, and the type of report you have been asked to produce.The amount of time allocated for the assessment will have been agreed with the instructing solicitor prior to the assessment.

Your assessment and information gathering will typically explore the claimant's pre-injury functional status, the physical, cognitive and psychological impairments arising from the injury, and how these have affected their ability to manage everyday activities, maintain relationships, participate in work and leisure, and engage in family and social life. You will also need to consider any medical treatment provided to date or planned future treatment or surgery.

You may consider the wider impact on those around them, including family members and informal carers, and the care, support and assistance they now require.

This all helps to build a comprehensive picture of the individual's journey since the injury, and their ongoing needs for support, equipment and rehabilitation moving forward.

Of course, the focus and scope of your assessment will vary depending on your professional background and area of expertise, and other disciplines may need to explore different or additional aspects of the claimant’s circumstances.

Step 4: Writing your report

This is where the real work often begins! You'll need to consider your assessment findings alongside the available records and reports, analyse the information and explain your professional opinion and recommendations clearly. A report template can be incredibly helpful. You can adapt it for each case, and it gives you a structure to work from rather than staring at a blank screen wondering where on earth to begin. Don't underestimate the time involved. You may need to revisit the records, seek clarification or request permission from your instructing solicitors to contact a treating therapist or case manager for further information. You'll also need to proofread your report, complete your costing schedules and ensure everything is accurate and ready for submission. The report then needs to be sent to your mentor for a quality assurance review, prior to it being emailed into head office.

My advice? Start your report as soon as possible after the assessment. I try to block out the following day wherever possible, so I can make a good start while everything is fresh in my mind. I then fill in any gaps over the following couple of weeks around my clinical work. Give yourself enough time. Rushing is stressful, and nobody needs that!

Step 5: Submitting your report

Once submitted, your report will be reviewed by the solicitors, who might come back with questions or requests for clarification. They may ask you to check factual details or consider another perspective. It's important to remain open to legitimate questions and correct any errors, but your opinion must remain your own. You should never feel pressured to change your independent opinion simply to suit someone else's case. If you disagree with a suggestion, explain your reasoning calmly and professionally.

Step 6: Waiting and reviewing

Once your report has been submitted, you might not hear anything for a very long time. The case may settle, and you may never find out the outcome. Alternatively, you might be asked to review additional records, revisit the claimant, provide an updated report or respond to new information. These requests can come months or even years after you have submitted your report. Sometimes, these requests arrive urgently, which can be challenging when you're juggling clinical work and other commitments.

Step 7: Conferences, discussions and joint statements

As the case progresses, you may be asked to attend a conference with the barrister and solicitors, sometimes alongside other experts involved in the case. This is usually to review all the evidence and ensure that it is ready for service to the opposing side. You may also be asked to review the opposing expert's report and take part in a discussion with them to identify areas of agreement and disagreement. Together you will then work towards producing a joint statement setting out your respective positions. In both of these instances, you will be required to explain and justify your opinion clearly. Remember to remain professional, independent and open to the evidence at all times.

Step 8: Court – potentially!

Most cases settle before reaching a final court hearing, but you should be prepared for the possibility that you may be called to give oral evidence. This is where your preparation, understanding of your report and ability to explain your reasoning become particularly important. I would strongly recommend attending some court skills training. It’s always best to be prepared, and knowing what to expect from the court process will help you to keep calm and focused.

Final words

The key thing to remember is that expert witness work doesn't necessarily end when you submit your report. There may be considerably more work to follow, sometimes long after you've mentally moved on to the next case! And once you’ve accepted a case, it’s yours until the end - you can’t decide mid case that you no longer want to work on it, or have the time for it. Throughout all these steps, it is important that you have the right support. An experienced and reputable expert witness company, such as Maggie Sargent & Associates, will be there to guide you through each step, making your role as an expert witness a much less stressful one.

Next up and last in this article series, Building up your reputation and top tips for success.

‍

‍